Narcissism in Ministry

Tuesday

I've been noodling a lot about narcissism lately. First off, I worry I'm narcisissistic. How much of my day revolves around my wants, my supposed needs, my desires? Having grown up as an only child can do that to someone. Perhaps the reason God sends stress and pain into my life is to keep the self-absorbed me from taking over myself entirely. Thank You Jesus for trials!

But here's the thing I've been wondering about: the link between entitlement and narcisissism and ministry. When we come to a place in our lives where we feel we're entitled to certain things, we embody narcisissism.

I've (unfortunately) encountered Christian workers who believe the world owes them things: applause, money, glory, time. That because they are doing this difficult thing for Jesus, others should step up and gift them with all sorts of things. When I've seen this, I've wanted to vomit. What about joy? What about serving Jesus, not for material or personal gain, but simply for His sake? What about the paradox of suffering joyfully for His Name?

I've met people who firmly believe it's the Body of Christ's job to take Christian workers out to dinner, to shower them with blessings, to fix their houses, to pay for their children's schooling, because, after all, they're doing this hard thing for Jesus.

I've met people who appear to be working hard in ministry, but actually don't work at all. I've met people who hide their sins behind the veil of ministry. I've met people who go into ministry to run away from their glaring and blatant sin issues. I've met people in ministry who are more than willing to share how you're wrong, but crucify you back if you dare bring up one sin issue. I've met people who abuse their families while studying theology. I've met people who've gone into ministry simply because it afforded them credibility, the perfect facade to cover up what is dying underneath.

I once knew someone who wanted to capitalize on a child's grave illness by taking a picture and sending it to supporters. "We got the most support that month," he boasted, as if he'd found the correct method for extracting the most money from folks.

If being in ministry is about the money we get, the prestige we have, the indulgences we cherish, the ability to hide behind an acceptable Christian facade, then we are walking on the wrong road. The road is wide, Jesus said, that leads to destruction. The road is narrow, leading to Him. And that road has nothing--nothing--to do with narcissism. Since when did Christianity have anything to do with demanding to be served?

If we believe that the world exists for us in some sort of narcissistic love fest, we are gravely wrong. If we mistake the generosity of others as our due reward, we miss the mark. It's not that others owe us, it's that we owe Him everything.

Am I alone here? Perhaps I'm jaded and cynical. But I can't help but think this breaks God's heart. I can't help but resonate with those Scriptures about wolves in sheep's clothing. I'd never thought of those verses when I was a young Christian. I believed everyone. I trusted every person in ministry. I elevated them to pedestal status. But now I've grown up.

Maybe that's why I love my church so much. It's not a perfect church, but it's honest. And the leaders have a strong work ethic, good accountability, evident moral character, and a desire to see God's kingdom (not theirs) advanced. If it wasn't for this church, I'd despair.

I've seen enough in my years as an adult Christian that makes me wary of anyone who calls him or herself a minister. Prove it to me. By your actions. (Hmmm, the book of James comes to mind here). Because, folks, I've heard enough lying words to know words can be very persuasive and enticing, but also dead wrong. We have, according to my friend Hud, an almost limitless capacity to self-deceive. If we write or say enough words about our greatness (ah, narcissism!), we'll believe our own press, and others will too.

I have written this before, but I rest in these two words: GOD SEES. He sees those who serve Him for their own gain. I'm scraping by, cowering under Paul's beautiful audacity, to rejoice that even so, Christ is proclaimed. I'm not there yet. All I can see is neglect and abuse of God's high holy calling. But He sees. He knows when others serve Him to hide. Or to gain financial freedom. Or to be showered with earthly praise. Or to be served. He sees.

All I can do is grab His hand, entreat Him to please-please-please deliver me from my own ugly narcissism, and tenderize my cynical heart. Because, believe me, the last thing I want to do is go into ministry right now.

16 comments:

Katy McKenna said...

I heard a minister last weekend say that Americans in general (including Christians, politicians, those in almost every profession except some in the "caring" professions, and children) have become "takers." Sometimes I mistakenly believe it's just those who refuse to work who think they're "entitled." But the privileged believe the same way. We're "entitled" to keep everything we've earned, and to spend it on our pleasure. Ouch!!! I am encouraged by one.org and the Idolgivesback campaign. Raising $60 mil in two nights is not half bad. Imagine what America could do if we as individuals got out of debt, stopped spending ourselves into oblivion, and made lifestyles our of being givers instead of takers. I know my comments aren't as specific as your subject, Mary. But I blogged about "entitlement" today, too.

In my personal life, I need to make a seismic shift from taking to giving. And it needs to last for the rest of my natural life.

Katy www.fallible.com

Tami Boesiger said...

While I understand your disappointment and have witnessed many of the things you've discussed in this post, please do not underestimate the tremendous pressure those in the ministry are under. How are they to possibly meet all the many expectations placed upon them? Is it fair to criticize actions you have not heard the entire story on? How can you possibly know what is in their heart?

"Do not judge, and you will not be judged. Do not condemn, and you will not be condemned. Forgive, and you will be forgiven." (Luke 6:37)

Instead of attacking them, shouldn't you be praying for them?

relevantgirl said...

Tami,

I do pray for folks like this. You've misunderstood my post, or perhaps I wrote it with far too much hurt and pain. I'm not speaking of ministers who faithfully give. I'm writing about wolves in sheep's clothing who believe it their aim to take the highest place at gatherings, to be entitled to special treatment, to use ministry as a means to hide sin.

Suzan Robertson said...

Entitlement is a word that should be left out of a Christian's vocabulary. If we got what we deserved, we'd all be in hell. Instead, we got grace, heaven and Jesus.

Great post, Mary.
Don't stop speaking God's truth!

Paula said...

At the beginning and end of your post you talked about your own struggle with narcissism. It reminded me of something I experienced as a young mother several years ago. My husband was employed with Promise Keepers and had given so much of his soul to serving God in this way. For him it was a genuine delight to be involved in a place where God moved and changed lives. He strove to be a servant leader.

Then things changed at PK and hundreds of people were laid off. Eventually, it was my husband's turn. We entered a difficult season with four small children and no income. It didn't seem to matter in the business world that my husband had managed people or programs in his positions of ministry (PK wasn't the first "ministry" job). They seemed to believe his positions in ministry didn't mean he had skills transferable to the "real world." It was a hard time trying to find a way to support our family.

Over the next year or two we bumped into many of the old PK workers crowd. Almost all of them had a difficult story of unemployment, illness, or other very hard times.

I asked God what was up with that.

And one day I let my own narcissism and entitlement pour out. I still remember where I was driving--on this little spur of a road near my home.

"God," I cried out, "these people loved and served you. Of all people, you should be taking care of them (us)."

Immediately, I felt the Spirit's rebuke. He quickly let me know that serving didn't make us entitled to special favor. I realized I had it all wrong. He doesn't owe us for serving Him. We are privileged to do so.

Sometimes I still grapple with this issue, though. It is during these times that it helps me to remember that there is an enemy who wants to take from us--that when we serve we are choosing to step into a battle for our Lord. Do we really think we can serve on the front lines without being attacked?

My experience has been that during times of great attack I am again tempted to question my Lord's heart for me. I'm learning to lean into Him instead of accuse Him, but I don't do it perfectly. There are still those times of entitlement and narcissism and whining.

Pattie said...

I found this post interesting, as I usually find your posts. I know you've been a missionary, so you know what it's like to scrape by and work hard for a pittance and very little glory and honor. My husband pastored small congregations for eighteen years (ranging in size from 12 members at the tiny end, to 100 members at the largest end), and it was only after choosing to go active duty in the military, that he is making an above-poverty salary by himself (I've had to work most of our marriage). I haven't seen all of what you've seen, but I have seen pastors with large salaries and houses be respected and adored by their large church congregations, while we struggled. That's tough to swallow. (Hm, perhaps I have not let go of as much as I thought I had!)

David A. Zimmerman said...

I just surfed my way over here, only to find you discussing my favorite topic lately: narcissism. I particularly enjoyed this line: "When I've seen this, I've wanted to vomit." Caught me off guard. Nice post. I don't know if you've run across the book Dear Church: Letters from a Disillusioned Generation, but the author communicates some of the same frustrations you're articulating here. The challenge, I think, comes in the collision of narcissisms. I had an interesting discussion with some friends the other day about the idea of "shattered narcissism" as the common condition of human beings: our fall did permanent damage to our self-regard, and so now we can't think rightly of ourselves without thinking wrongly of the people around us. I think it's probably fine for people in vocational ministry to wish people would offer some sort of expression of care from time to time, but to think of it in terms of quid pro quo does cheapen their ministry. I note that the apostle Paul complained about having to raise funds for himself but refused to give up the privilege. The focus then stayed on the growth that needed to happen in his audience rather than some sort of self-justification for him. The prophet Samuel did something similar when he put the smack down on the Israelites in their demand for a king.

Nice post. Good to meet you.

Ron Benson said...

Mary,

I was busy getting my yacht ready for the first day of sailing when I read your post on my Blackberry and thought I'd pop into my summer cottage to drop you a note...

Seriously, I too get nauseated when I encounter the kind of "minister" you write about. They're out there, and they do major damage.

I've been a pastor for nearly 25 years, and I grew up as a PK. I've been surrounded by "ministry professionals" forever, and I consider the word an oxymoron.

Here's what I mean: While there are glaring examples of the kind of narcissism you describe, and while there are, I believe, some nearly-perfect suffering saints that serve in obscurity and always with a smile, most of us are in the middle of the continuum.

I know it's true for me. I have to fight the beast of leadership arrogance sometimes, and I've had to be slapped down by God on occasion. I've used the ministry to salve my pain, and I like getting kudos when I preach well.

On the other hand, I desire to follow Jesus, to be like him more and more, and to love people like he loved them.

Narcissism is just another word for "sin nature." It's a matter of degree--maturity and obedient faith. There is no such thing as a "ministry professional." We're all amatuers.

Your words forced me to again think through "the call." What is that? How does it weave through a life and a family? Does God use the status of personal economy to lead us into his will? In my own case, do I return to "full-time Christian service," or continue to "lose ground" pursuing a passion to write that I still believe came from God?

I counsel with several wounded pastors. One had to close a church and is now considered a pariah among his peers. Another works folding laundry at a hospital in order to continue ministering to a church where he is continually abused. A third has labored faithfully for thirty years in an urban ministry but constantly feels like a loser because he has not seen "growth" as measured by the expectations of his vision.

These guys all love Jesus. They believe they are called and are serving where God wants them.

I also know many people who have lost faith in the church altogether because of puffed up, whiney, co-dependent leaders like you describe.

So, what's the answer? I don't think it's complicated.

I have a lot more to say on this one, but I have to go polish my Mercedes.

julia said...

i see this is a post from a few years back, but i'm fascinated by the whole narcissism thing, having come from a home where at least one parent was narcissistic. i've known many pastors and leaders over my years in church, most of them real, flawed people like me. But the one who left the gaping wound so hard to forget? A narcissistic pastor who set himself the grand (and secret) goal of cleansing the church of the blue-collar types, but shrouding it in false accusations.

Easy for me to remember those who minister solely for their own purposes, not those of God. They do make an impact.

Gary said...

2 Peter and Jude would be good follow-up to read here.

gary.

telemicus said...

Mary, first, like it or not - you are in ministry. Second, I generally feel that good Christians hammer on themselves too much, while the pseudo-Christians (no such thing as a bad Christian) dont see any weakness or failure at all. The Lord's comments in Luke 17:6-10 solve the entitlement attitude ('We are unworthy servants; we have only done our duty.') You're no narcissist. If you want to hurt your head in reference to this subject, give 'The Force of Truth' (Scott) a read.

shepherdsgrace said...

I thought Ron's description was apt...Paul said the sin was present when he was trying to do good, the battle, I think, will remain until we die and then...

what utter freedom, no more sin mixed with service, no more pride interlaced with performance, only joy with our Master...

May He come soon...

Rachel said...

This is an old post, but I saw it come through on my Facebook feed and thought I'd check it out.

True narcissism is something I never thought I'd deal with. It was just one of those things that people talk about. I got married last spring and over the course of the last seven months he proved himself to be a textbook narcissist who is incapable of telling the truth. We're now married in name only and I'm back home with my parents.

I can definitely say I've been deeply hurt by narcissism. Shattered, in fact. Everyone has it to some degree, it's part of our fallen sin nature. But some people do take it so far that they end up destroying everyone around them.

My pastor is fond of saying that we're all a little narcissistic and all a little nuts. But those of us who have truly embraced our salvation and approach it with the right attitude are able, with God's help, to overcome our narcissistic tendencies.

Danica/Dream said...

GOD SEES. I needed to hear this today. And I think, as I'm dealing with a number of injustices, including having to deal with narcissistic people, those two words give me a lot of comfort. God sees. In the end, they will have to stand before Him and answer to Him. He sees who they really are. I think I may have to write GOD SEES on my mirror as a reminder.

Mary DeMuth said...

Danica, I'm glad it helped.

Gwen Stewart said...

Mary,

What a great post, and timely for me.

I'm a schoolteacher. In the last twenty-five years, the "self-esteem" movement has damaged our children, youth, and now young adults. The statistics are alarming: while forty years ago, 30% of the American population tested narcissistic, that percentage is now a whopping 70%. Additionally, more than 70% of recent college graduates believe they are more attractive AND more intelligent than "average" folks.

The church has done little, perhaps nothing, to quell the trend in the wider culture. What do we tell our children from birth? "God loves you". Of course that's true, and certainly a message they need to absorb! But I'm afraid that's the meat of the message throughout their growth. We tell them the love; we don't tell them the sin. Because "sin" is too close to "bad", and no child should ever, ever suffer being told they're wrong, bad or naughty. They're wonderful just the way they are; no improvement projects necessary. Certainly not the painful, lance-the-boil work the Spirit longs to work in them.

I haven't the mission experience you do, just the perspective of a Christian public school teacher (yes, we do exist! :-). If the church doesn't learn to recognize and counteract narcissism, I believe we'll continue to experience it within church ranks...and the church will be unequipped to master the tenacity and strength of character necessary to withstand the tough but necessary work of the Spirit.

God bless you today.